the regina mom is pleased to see that at least the NDP are taking the misogynistic and ageist personal attack by Senator Dagenais against MP Charmaine Borg seriously. In the House of Commons on Monday, MP Charlie Angus asked if the PMO was involved. Not surprisingly, the Prime Minister’s Parliamentary Secretary, MP Paul Calandra, gave a non-response. [Beginning at 1:00]
MP Charmaine Borg, who is regarded as a good and hard-working MP, has lodged a formal complaint with the Speaker of the House.
In the letter, which was copied to all MPs, senators and their staff, Dagenais characterized Borg as a whiny, ignorant, useless Quebec MP who was elected by fluke and stands little chance of being re-elected.
Dagenais’ letter was sent in response to a flyer Borg sent out in her riding advocating the NDP’s long-held belief that the Senate should be abolished.
Borg says she was particularly insulted by Dagenais’ suggestion that she should get some books from the parliamentary library to inform herself about the Senate before criticizing the institution.
Borg, who is just 23 years old, says that’s the kind of “old-school mentality” that discourages young women from entering politics.
“The overall tone of this letter suggests that I am simply a little girl who does not take her work seriously,” Borg told the Commons on Monday.
“I think if I was an old, white man, he would not have attacked me,” Ms. Borg, 23, told reporters. “We’re not doing any favours to young women who want to run in the future by having this type of behaviour in Parliament.”
Ms. Borg said the letter was “condescending,” pointing out that she took political science classes at McGill University and is well-versed in constitutional matters.
“If his letter contained real facts, had a real debate about ideas, then I wouldn’t be here having a question of privilege in the House,” Ms. Borg said.
She added it’s “very ironic” that the attack originates from an unelected senator.
“He was a failed candidate, and then a year later, was named by the Prime Minister as a senator,” Ms. Borg said. “I don’t think he has any place to challenge my legitimacy.”
And, Ms Borg appeared on CBC’s Power and Politics.
trm was very happy to see that; it takes a lot of courage to stand up to a bully! trm particularly loves that Ms Borg challenged Dagenais to step down from his Senate seat to run against her in 2015! Oh, that young woman has spunk! trm looks forward to more from Ms Borg!
Several years ago, the regina mom wrote a letter to the editor of the local daily newspaper, accusing the Premier of the day of misogyny. trm received supreme shit from an older male family member for doing so because it forced him to look up the definition in the dictionary and because she dared to call a man a “woman-hater.” Well, there are some very subtle ways of expressing hatred toward women and trm wishes a few more people, particularly those in the Senate and the House of Commons would do some digging and come to an understanding of how misogyny works.
Take, for example the attack Senator Dagenais delivered to NDP MP Charmaine Borg and cc’d to all Senators, several media outlets and all Members of Parliament because Ms Borg sent a flyer critical of the Senate to her constituents. Perhaps people in Quebec are not aware that the NDP has a long-standing policy to abolish the Senate and reading about that set the Senator off. Perhaps Dagenais was reminded that he lost an election next door to Borg in the 2011 election and he still feels bitter about that. Perhaps he spent too much time as a police officer. Who knows? But here is Dagenais’ letter to Borg, from Nathan Cullen’s Facebook page:
Member for Terrebonne-Blainville
House of Commons
Ottawa, Ontario K1A OA6
What a rag!
That is the only word I can think of to describe the pamphlet that you sent to citizens in the riding at the expense of all Canadian taxpayers.
As an NDP MP, who would likely never have been elected without Quebecers’ spontaneous sympathy for Jack Layton, who appointed a bunch of puppets to fill the holes in several of the province’s ridings, did you know that the abolition of the Senate that you’re talking about isn’t even part of the NDP’s platform? And you certainly don’t know enough about constitutional matters to be making such claims. There is a well-stocked library on the subject, available to you in Parliament, and I suggest you use it.
Under the circumstances, I understand that you are blindly parroting your leader Thomas Mulcair to denigrate the Senate and its senators. Can you remind him that he has wasted enough time in the House of Commons, where other priorities like the economy, jobs and security could have been discussed in recent months for the good of the country? However, with a program as weak as yours, I understand that he may not have anything else to talk about.
I hope that the results of the recent by-elections will make him reflect on your chances of returning to Parliament in the next general elections.
Because you believe that senators are useless, allow me to inform you that since the election of NDP MPs in Quebec, I have been asked on numerous occasions by citizens and organizations in your riding to intervene in government matters. When I suggested that they first go and talk to their MP, they all responded that you were useless and powerless to do anything. Make a note of that and tell your colleagues. You can even tell them that it gave me some pleasure to hear that.
Parliamentary life, Ms. Borg, is not just about whining, although you’ve become very good at it and the media certainly takes delight in it. Canadians and a large majority of Quebecers recognize that we have a healthy economy thanks to the Conservatives and they continue and certainly will continue to reject your socialist ideas.
Conservative senator and citizen of Blainville
According to trm‘s friends at DAMMITJANET! the MSM has been glossing over the misogyny of the attack, taking the lead from Harper harpie Stephen Taylor who suggests the unsuggestable, that naming it as sexist weakens the definition of sexist. How he purports to know anything about that makes trm want to bash her head against a wall. Remember, these are the boys and girls who took the word “equality” out of the mandate of Status of Women Canada! And this Senator was appointed by the Prime Minister.
The letter is a demeaning, dismissive and shaming personal attack and has no place in Canadian politics. trm invites you to demonstrate support for Ms Borg by demanding the Senator apologize to her. Regardless how you feel about the Senate, surely we can all agree that this kind of behavior is exactly what drives people — especially women — away from politics. Borg has been an excellent, hard-working MP and should be encouraged, not abused, for her good work. Getting a rise out of a Conservative Senator, though possibly a badge of honour, can negatively impact a person. trm wants to make sure the impact of positive support from the grassroots is stronger. Please take a moment to demand an apology. And cc it far and wide. Email addresses and additional information are below.
Senate of Canada
Toll Free: 1-800-267-7362
Charmaine Borg, MP
House of Commons
Web Site:*www.charmaineborg.info/ (in French only)
Preferred Language: French
Consider cc’ing your message to
Prime Minister Stephen Harper firstname.lastname@example.org
Thomas Mulcair, Leader of the Official Opposition email@example.com
Niki Ashton, Opposition Critic on the Status of Women firstname.lastname@example.org
Justin Trudeau, Leader of the Liberal Party of Canada email@example.com
Kirsty Duncan, Status of Women Critic, Liberal Party firstname.lastname@example.org
Elizabeth May, Leader of the Green Party of Canada email@example.com
ADDITIONAL BACKGROUND INFORMATION:
Maclean’s Magazine: http://bit.ly/1gNzRfe
Borg’s Member of Parliament Profile Page: http://bit.ly/1hEUD3C
Borg’s NDP-NPD page: http://www.charmaineborg.info/
Borg on Katimavik at rabble.ca: http://bit.ly/1csI6fT
Wikipedia Page on Charmaine Borg: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charmaine_Borg
Michael Geist on Charmaine Borg: http://www.michaelgeist.ca/content/view/6794/125/
NDP note on Harper’s Senate Appointments
Dagenais and China: http://www.roc-taiwan.org/MX/ct.asp?xItem=432360&ctNode=2240&mp=1
Today is the 24th anniversary of the Montreal Massacre, that day in 1989 when 14 women were gunned down because they were women. Today, we make a point of remembering:
Without a doubt, these are interesting times for those who, like the regina mom, follow Canadian politics. The Senate Scandal aka the Wright-Duffy Affair aka Prime Minister Harper’s Watergate has legs and continues to run, despite Margaret Wente’s mad ravings in the Globe and Mail.
I love a juicy scandal. What better way to fill a column than stories about greedy, lying politicians getting their comeuppance, and secret payoffs, and explosive revelations, and the decline of democracy as we know it? Besides, Stephen Harper is not most people’s favourite guy. So it pains me to report that despite the most recent breathless headlines, the Senate scandal has run out of legs.
Wrong, Marg. Today, the Prime Minister’s Office announced that the Privy Council Office found the missing email messages from former PMO legal adviser Benjamin Perrin!
The Privy Council Office has informed the RCMP that emails belonging to Benjamin Perrin, the former counsel for the Prime Minister’s Office named in court documents related to a deal between Nigel Wright and Senator Mike Duffy, were not deleted as was previously believed.
In fact, Perrin’s account had been frozen “due to unrelated litigation.”
“We regret that we previously failed, even if inadvertently, to accurately inform you [the RCMP] and the PMO about the availability of Mr. Perrin’s emails,” the PCO says in a letter to the RCMP. “We apologize for any inconvenience it may have caused.”
The PCO says it will turn the email records over to the RCMP immediately.
Back in May when this story was just growing its legs, Perrin said he had nothing to do with the mess.
I was not consulted on, and did not participate in, Nigel Wright’s decision to write a personal cheque to reimburse Senator Duffy’s expenses.
I have never communicated with the Prime Minister on this matter.
In all my work, I have been committed to making our country a better place and I hope my record of service speaks for itself.
Is Perrin going to be the next one thrown under the PM’s bus? Will this finally be the end of Stephen Harper as PM? Or is something else going on here?
trm asks that last question because she noticed a lot of wet pants on Twitter over the weekend, following the National Post‘s publication of Andrew Coyne’s piece praising CPC MP Michael Chong’s proposed Reform Act.
Should it pass, Parliament would never be the same again. The bill would fundamentally recast the relationship between party leaders and caucuses, and with it the whole structure of our politics. The balance of power would shift, irrevocably, in favour of MPs and their riding associations, and away from the leaders and their apparatchiks. In sum, this is a vastly consequential bill, and fully deserving of the historical echoes in its short title: The Reform Act 2013.
Though the Act has yet to see the light of day, Tweeps were raving about it, under the #ReformAct hashtag. It seems to trm that Canadians are so eager to rid the country of Stephen Harper that they’ll take the first thing that comes along — sight unseen — to do so. If other parties had a one member, one vote system of electing a leader they’d be less eager to legislate power away from the parties’ grassroots. Or, if Conservative Party Members of Parliament had courage they’d stand up to the PM.
As far as trm is concerned, it’s dangerous to make decisions based on what pundits say or about something not yet available to read. But saying so on Twitter does not make one a lot of friends. Chong was going to present it on Thursday but has since changed his mind and will now do so on Tuesday.
Since the text of the bill has not been released, there has been much speculation about its intent. The bill should not be viewed as a critique on any of the current leaders in the House of Commons. To suggest otherwise, misinterprets the intent of the bill.
Due to the interest surrounding the content of the bill, I have decided to introduce it in the House of Commons earlier than previously planned. This will allow me to release the text of the bill to the public and explain its content to Canadians.
This is all well and good — and lookit! There’s a website, too! But isn’t it interesting that it will fall in the news cycle immediately following stories about the almost magical finding of Perrin’s emails?
trm has many more questions! She hopes the scandal doesn’t get lost in the hullaballoo already publicizing the Reform Act.
the regina mom firmly believes the HarperCons stole the 2011 election to secure their Majority government. And so, she has been hoping that there would be a way to stop it. Learning the truth about the Robofraud scandal seemed the most likely, until now.
The past few weeks have shown trm that Tom Mulcair is an amazing Parliamentarian, holding the Prime Minister to account on the Senate-PMO scandal. The PM’s stumbling response, repeating the same story, has only made the situation worse for the poor PM. Even his own people are turning against him!
As if Senator Gerstein, PM Harper and his smear-boy, Paul Calandra, had not received a sstern enough chiding from bloggers, tweeters and the mainstream media, in comes CTV’s Don Martin, with the most scathing and convincing takedown to day. trm believes it’s a must-watch for all Canadians! GO: When the government speaks, the only consistency is inconsistency itself.